What the flip?
Today, the 23rd of Sivan, is the date on which Haman’s decree against the Jews was flipped – “ונהפוך הוא” – and Mordechai’s decree in favor of the Jews was sent out (Esther 8:9).
In a beautiful depiction of that story, the 3rd century synagogue of Dura Europos on the Euphrates illustrates Haman’s plans of self-aggrandizement being flipped into his humiliation:
Haman took the garb and the horse and arrayed Mordecai and paraded him through the city square; and he proclaimed before him: “This is what is done for the man whom the king desires to honor!”Esther 6:8
Some hold that this is a good day (Segulah) to pray for evils and tragic situations to “flip out” into a better outcome. By gollie, we need some serious flipping out now, so please pray!
Image is from Wikimedia Commons, text from Sefaria.org
Babylon: Myth and Reality (Nov 13, 2008-Mar 15, 2009) is an exhibition that changed my life – even though I had never seen it.
It was my father who visited this British Museum exhibition and brought home the catalogue (“the Babylon book”). Shortly after this, in 2010, I volunteered to teach the Book of Daniel to a class of thirty-seven 8th graders in Jerusalem, and where I was teaching as an undergraduate student-teacher. Using the resources I learned about through this book, I inspired these adolescents who were previously intimidated by the mostly-Aramaic book. This experience had made the book approachable to them, and the importance of archaeology for me – tangible.
At the end of the year, we celebrated with Nebuchadnezzar’s Ishtar Gates of Babylon – on a cake designed by yours truly.
End-of-year celebration, after learning the Book of Daniel. Jerusalem, 2010
The next part of this story was completely unexpected. Since those student-teacher days, I’ve been teaching professionally in the US for six years, and often guiding tours near the two real Ishtar Gate lions on display at the Met. Academically I’ve gone back to school, completing an M.Ed in Jewish Education at the Hebrew University in Jerusalem, and currently studying for an MA in Ancient Jewish History at Bernard Revel Graduate School (Yeshiva University). It is in this context that I had the distinct pleasure of seeing Dr. Michael Seymour, co-author of the Babylon book.
Dr. Seymour moderated a symposium for The World Between Empires Met exhibition (Mar 18-Jun 23, 2019). This spectacular exhibition shows the complexities of life, religion, commerce and identity in the region between Roman and Parthian Empires; the two superpowers of the late Second Temple period to the 3rd century CE.
This was only possible thanks to my professor at Revel, Steven Fine, inviting students to the symposium.
During that symposium, I was reminded of how my journey began 9 years ago. But it was only later, as I was guiding a private tour in the World Between Empires, that I recognized Dr. Seymour as he spoke to a group, and introduced myself. We kept in touch, met again when I was guiding students, and finally sat down for an early Friday morning coffee at the museum.
We sat and told lots of stories about shared interests. It was a fascinating conversation, and hopefully just the first of many.
Dr. Seymour is an assistant curator in the Met since 2011, when he began work on the exhibition Assyria to Iberia at the Dawn of the Classical Age (Sep 22, 2014-Jan 4, 2015). This was the very first exhibition I saw, on my very first Met visit.
I had brought along my copies of the Babylon and World Between Empires books, which are now autographed in a place of honor on my bookshelf.
We never know who we will touch and how we will make an impact. Whether it’s something we say, an act of kindness that we do, or a book that we write.
The impact that Dr. Seymour had on my life in turn had an impact on my students’ learning, on my career path, and down the line – on countless other lives which were inspired and invigorated because of some old rocks someone dug out of the dirt in Ancient Babylon!
Be the change that you wish to see in the worldMahatma Gandhi
Starting from the Bottom Up
It is 2019, and the grassroots, bottom-up approach has been proving itself to be the way change happens. This is happening in so many fields, including education – and there is no reason why it should not apply to Jewish Education.
How do we adapt?
The internet, technology and social media have changed the way we interact. They are vying for our attention, and that of our children. It has a losing battle, once you allow that small device into the home – and I am not here to say that you should or should not do that. What I am saying is that, the impact on the Jewish Educational system is inescapable.
Where do we make the change?
How do we make a difference?
How can we get our school on board?
I am a firm believer in the vitality and relevance of Torah to our life. I believe that the goal of a Jewish Education system cannot be just to convey information or preparing for a BJE test. There has to be a deep commitment to, and belief in, the reality of Torah. Only with that in mind, can we proceed with confidence into the unknown future of Jewish education, learning, leadership and change.
As a jewish-educational-entrepreneur (for lack of a better title), I work tirelessly to convey this message to laypeople, parents, schools, administrations, synagogues and publications. Having spoken to many schools and rabbis and community leaders in the past three years, I realized that the change cannot come from the top down.
Schools, institutions – they are all systems that have to run a certain way. They have a tremendous amount of responsibility to their parent bodies, congregants, and general clientele. This is both a vital part of the system, and what can make it very hard to move, when necessary.
That is where I come in. I believe that with social media, today, we can engage people in new ways. Not only students. I am not talking about creating multimillion dollar online curriculum – that has its place. I am talking about inspiring educators and just simply – Jews – to respond to the call of Torah. To realize that it is real, that it can be vitalized in the classroom or the synagogue without expensive materials, without learning new curriculum but rather, with a change in approach.
This week I took action.
I spoke to several colleagues who are on board with me, and said “guys, let’s do an Instagram Live session on this De’Ara Tanach Map”. We have been trying for two years to figure out the logistics of doing this with our own school, while I am traveling the country doing this with other schools. Instead of talking about it – let’s be the change we want to see.
To find out more about the map, and see a video about it: http://foundationstone.org/Store/store.html
The results we incredible. The three teachers were super-energized and excited about the possibilities of integrating this simple and powerful tool. Social media is playing its part, and we are reaching people in new ways, bringing the change from the bottom up. Here is a short video from the excitement:
A spontaneous get-together between Brooklinian friends, celebrating a birthday on a Saturday night. And what better place to celebrate than – the Brooklyn Museum!
On the first Saturday of the month, the Brooklyn Museum is open – and free – until 11PM. It’s all a buzz, with DJs, dancing, music and lots of noise – and vibrance. We chose this need to do a casual walk-through tour, highlighting anything from #InfiniteBlue – and Lapis Lazuli, to Ancient Near East: Assyria and Egypt.
More pictures coming later. And meanwhile:
Returning customers, especially for the same tour, is very encouraging. Both pictures are of today’s group at the Metropolitan Museum.
The right-hand picture is of returning customers from last year. Mrs. Gitta Neufeld, head of educational development at Allegra Franco School of Educational Leadership (second from right) attended my tour in June 2017, and hired me as a teacher at Allegra Franco. I am looking forward to beginning my second year teaching there.
Take it from her:
(amidst the hustle and bustle of the Met’s closing hours – this is being cleaned up slightly, but bear with us for 22 seconds!)
This week, Parashat Tzav and the Shabbat before Pesach, is called שבת הגדול – the “Great” or “Grand” Sabbath.
Why is it called Shabbat Hagadol?
School children learn the story of how the Hebrews tied the pascal lamb to the bedpost on the sabbath before the very first Passover in Egypt. But this was a risky thing to do, as the Egyptians deified the lamb. However, G-d protected us and it was a grand display of His benevolence that not a single Egyptian tried to hurt us for holding their gods at bay.
But come now, seriously?
On a Museum tour with ninth graders from Magen David Yeshivah High School, which I lead in early March, a student discovered a Ptolemaic period deity in the form of a ram – representing the Egyptian god Amun-Re, often represented in that form.
This student will never forget that!
Meet Abir Nassee, a master storyteller and over 45-year owner of the Oil Press Gallery in Jerusalem’s Old City.
Come in with me as we see his gallery, hear stories and see wonderful thing.
Part 1: Intro video
Part 2: The tour
“And in that day…the strayed who are in the land of Assyria…shall come and worship G-d on the holy mount, in Jerusalem (Isaiah 27:13)”
The mystery surrounding the vanishing of the Ten Tribes and their current whereabouts is nowhere near unraveled. Although recent studies into the topic have picked up the gauntlet, it is still shrouded in mystery.
Even the legends we have about their whereabouts are mysterious, or perhaps even mystical: Somewhere beyond the magical Sambation River , named for its impassable torrential currents which only settle on the Sabbath, effectually undermining any attempt to cross it during the week— as the Lost Tribes beyond it are all Sabbath-observant. Thus, they are in effect cut off from the rest of civilization. Google Earth, anyone?
While I cannot comment on that tradition, I would like to revisit the story of the exile itself, and raise some questions and usable aspects for a conversation about the Ten Lost Tribes.
In my first article in this series, “Wine and Prophecy: The Rebirth of Shomron”, I discussed the basic biblical narrative. From passages of Assyrian and Babylonian chronologies, as well as verses in Jeremiah and in the Talmud, it appears that the story isn’t as simple as it seems.
In this article, I will explore three areas:
- Factoids from Assyrian and Babylonian records.
- Lost or amongst us?
- What hat did they wear? Implications towards religious practice.
Assyrian and Babylonian Records
First Waves of Assyria
The appearance of Assyria on the Biblical scene is very early on, and helps us relate to the names of important cities pertinent to excavations in Ancient Near Eastern archaeology: Babylon, Akkad (Akkadian), Nineveh, Kalah (Calah, Kalhu, etc), Uruk (Erekh), etc:
Kush also begot Nimrod, who was the first man of might on earth.
He was a mighty hunter by the grace of G-d; hence the saying, “Like Nimrod a mighty hunter by the grace of G-d.”
The mainstays of his kingdom were Babylon, Erech, Akkad, and Kalneh in the land of Shinar.
From that land Asshur went forth and built Nineveh, Rehoboth-ir, Kalah, and Resen between Nineveh and Kalah, that is the great city. (Gen 10:8-12)
A visit to any major museum containing Assyrian or Babylonian artifacts is bound to have references to some of these cities, which are the biblical setting of many stories.
First Mention of the Kings of Israel
The Assyrian Empire came on the scene before the Kingdom of Israel became subjugated to, and ultimately destroyed by, the Assyrian Empire in stages. For example, King Menahem, who ruled in Samaria a few years before the first exile, paid tribute to Tiglath Pileser III (II Kings 15:19-20), which appears on a royal stele in the Israel Museum. But this is from when the Assyrian Empire started expanding quickly and aggressively, of what is called the Neo-Assyrian Empire period.
In Assyrian record, earlier kings of Israel are mentioned paying tribute to the kings Ashurnasirpal II and Shalmaneser III, when Assyria was not in this expansion phase, but merely had dominance over some areas in Syria, which was short-lived (Van de Mieroop, M. p. 242-244).
In the Assyrian Kurkh Monolith, attributed to Ashurnasirpal II and Shalmaneser III, currently in the British Museum, Ahab King of Israel appears, and the House of Omri.
In the Black Obelisk of Shalmaneser III, also in the British Museum, King Yehu prostrates before the king (image below), escorted by tribute bearers. Both these kings lived roughly a century before the Neo-Assyrian Empire came on the scene.
Phoenicia and the Rebellion of Israel
The Neo-Assyrian involvement with Israel and Judah came when, according to II Kings 16:5, Kings Rezin of Aram (Damascus) and Pekah of Israel formed a coalition against King Ahaz of Judah. Their coalition was intended to block Ahaz from joining the Assyrian Empire and to keep out its foreign influence, a move which had devastating consequences to both Aram and Israel.
Ahaz became vassal to Assyria (ibid, 7), and thus saved his skin from the attack of the former two kings. However, what is not mentioned in the Biblical account is that there was another king involved in this coalition (Cogan, M. p. 67-72): Hiram of Tyre. 
The Phoenician King, bearing a similar name to the earlier Hiram who assisted Solomon in the building of the Temple in Jerusalem (I Kings 5:15), was no newcomer on the scene. The kingdoms of Israel and Phoenicia were allies since back in Ahab’s time, who married Jezebel daughter of Ethbaal of Tyre (I Kings 12:31). Besides building a house of worship for the Phoenician god Baal (ibid), Ahab also built himself an ivory house (II Kings 22:39). Fragments of ivory have been excavated in Ahab’s capital in ancient Samaria, known as the “Samaria Ivories”.
Back to our story – King Pekah of Israel is killed in a coup, and Hoshea assumed the throne (II Kings 15:30). According to Assyrian records, Hoshea was confirmed by Tiglath Pileser as king and vassal (Cogan M. p.72-76).
Hoshea rules Samaria for nine years (II Kings 17:1-6), while subjugated to Shalmaneser V. He is later caught sending an envoy to Egypt – a clear act of rebellion against Assyria – and is ultimately destroyed along with the deportation of the remainder of the Ten Tribes.
The surprise is that there was another king who takes credit for the capturing of Samaria. A king who is only mentioned once in the Bible, in relation to a campaign to Ashdod (Isaiah 20:1): Sargon II.
Sargon, who assumed the throne after Shalmaneser V, claims to have captured Samaria and been involved in the deportation process (Cogan p. 90-102). Even Babylonian chronicles attribute this capturing to him (Cogan, M. p. 209-211, 214). The subject of Sargon’s involvement in the region, and the way he records his campaign, is fascinating. For this article, as a segue into the next topic, I note just one point. While the initial campaign of Assyria Samaria, and its deportation, was initiated by Shalmaneser, it was clearly taking place over a prolonged period of time, in which at least one more king, if not several, were involved.
Lost or Amongst Us?
How long did it take to deport the Ten Tribes?
Mass deportation, while having existed earlier in Assyria, is a hallmark of Neo-Assyrian conquests. Different levels existed, from the deportation of specialist craftspeople to assist in various building projects, to deportation of entire regions – depending on its level of defiance (Van de Mieroop, M. p. 230-236).
This practice had several strategic benefits to the Assyrian Empire, while providing labour and people to build and inhabit its new cities. It reduced the opposition in the peripheral territories, as rebellious populations were resettled in foreign environments where they needed imperial protection against local hostility. Moreover, they would not escape, as they were unfamiliar with the country. Nor did they have the territorial imperative of fighting for their homeland. Nor did they have an organic group of their countrymen who would band together, as they were dispersed over wide areas, to either side of the Assyrian Empire’s homeland (according to Prof. Ran Zadok of Tel Aviv U.).
Furthermore, the territories of deported people were selectively resettled with other groups when they were crucial for trade or for the production of goods. This means that deportation was done very strategically, based on the skills of the deportees, and the necessities of the empire. For example, an area best suited for agriculture would be settled by agrarian peoples, and not by nomads.
And lastly, the supervision and feeding of large numbers of people during a voyage of several months must have required enormous organization, surprisingly not recorded for us.
All of this points to an important fact: Deportation was a gradual, and expensive, bureaucratic and administrative process. The deportation of the Ten Tribes could not have been carried out all at once, and while the area was being repopulated with foreigners who will come to be known as the Samaritans (II Kings 17:24-34), it is highly likely that members of the Ten Tribes continued to inhabit their homeland for decades after the destruction.
As mentioned in my previous article, the Seder Olam attributes the deportation to Sennacherib.
The book of Ezra describes how, during the rebuilding of the Second Temple in Jerusalem, Samaritans requested to assist in its building, noting that they have been integral to this land from the time of Esarhaddon (Ezra 4:2) – the successor of Sennacherib; while other nations’ presence is attributed to the last of the mighty Assyrian Kings – Ashurbanipal (ibid. 10)
All of this may help us understand how Jeremiah could fathomably have identified members of the Ten Tribes, and brought some of them back.
Jeremiah (3:6-26) describes a mission in which the prophet was sent to the north to bring back the lost tribes.
“Go, make this proclamation toward the North, and say: Turn back, O Rebel Israel—declares G-d. I will not look on you in anger, for I am compassionate—declares G-d; I do not bear a grudge for all time.”
Rav Yehuda Landy suggests that this was possible during the reign of Josiah King of Judah , since the Assyrian Empire was on a decline (p. 111). But this all points to a curious discussion about the preservation of some of the tribes in the nick of time. 
Are the Ten Tribes completely lost?
It is possible that those who remained suspended, awaiting deportation, had some interaction with, or influence from, Judea.
King Hezekiah (II Chro. ch. 30) sent invitations to Ephraim and Manasseh to join him in the Passover celebrations in Jerusalem, and some accepted the invitation, even staying in Judea.
The Talmud in Pesachim 4a  discusses how a person’s manner of speech may reveal an innate tribal association. (Writing this right after the public Torah reading of Vayechi, which describes the blessings of the various tribes, this seems quite timely.)
A certain man would regularly say whenever involved in conflict: Adjudicate my case [dunu dini]. The Sages said: Learn from it that he descends from the tribe of Dan, as it is written: “Dan will judge [ya-din] his people like one of the tribes of Israel” (Genesis 49:16).
The tribe of Dan was one of those exiled, as was Zebulun:
A certain man would regularly walk and say: The bushes on the seashore are cypresses, i.e., items located by the sea are more beautiful than those found in other places. They examined his lineage and found that he descends from the tribe of Zebulun, as it is written: “Zebulun shall dwell by the seashore” (Genesis 49:13).
All of these reveal some cracks in the notion that they are completely gone. But the mystery of the vanishing of the majority of their contingencies, still remains one of the big mysteries of Jewish History.
What Hat did They Wear? Implications towards Religious Practice
If you were to go on an expedition to find the Lost Tribes, what would you look for? What traditions, rituals or stories would you expect to find, that might shed light on Jewish origins?
Wait, Jewish origins?
After 2,000 years, we have grown used to identifying ourselves as Jews—of Judah.
What would the other Ten Tribes think of that?
Remember that the Ten Tribes succeeded from the Kingdom of Judah, actively denouncing any association with the Kingdom of Judah (I Kings 12:16). In fact, a member of the Kingdom of Israel would have probably taken offense at being called “Jew”.
“Are you talking to me?”
“I’m not from Judah—how dare you? I’m from Zebulun / Dan / Naphtali / Gad / Asher…”
Two kingdoms, geographically separated, ideologically unassociated, and often at war—for over two centuries. We are talking about different entities. And speaking of religion, the Kingdom of Israel on the surface seems to be a largely secular-oriented kingdom [Disclaimer: The Talmud and Midrashic literature record many significant interactions, discussions and events from the Kings of Israel, and the populace of Northern Israel demonstrating how they were very much in dialogue with tradition and religious practice. I would not dare subtract from that, and hope to do it better justice in the future]. The foreign influences, political marriages—the subject of much prophetic rebuke—and far-reaching trade and conquests, distinguished Israel from the more traditional Judah, with the Temple of Solomon in its capital, Jerusalem.
As for the Temple: For a long period of time, the kingdom of Israel forbade the pilgrimage to the Temple, seeing it as a threat to its own stability. 
And what is Judaism, if not a ritualistic “survival kit” for Jews in the diaspora, maintaining its adherers’ association with their land and tradition while in exile, with no land nor sovereignty. Most of what we would call religion, be it standardized prayers, blessings or rituals, and even the codification of the Oral Law into the Mishna and Talmud, were created after the Assyrian Exile, primarily by people of Judah.
And to really drive the point home. The method of Assyrian deportation was carefully constructed to insure that repopulated groups do not congregate in any meaningful way that would enable rebellion. The exile itself was so aggressive and abrupt, what means of scholarship would have survived in any form, and with the time required, to enable it to contemplate a religion?
All of that considered, what percentage of the society was learned enough to maintain a strong identity?
The Babylonian Exile was largely tranquil, once Jews settled in Babylon. Jews had a lot of autonomy, and scholarship was maintained, with the wherewithal to contemplate this newfound existence without a land or a Temple.
So what would you find, if you were to identify a descendant of any of the Tribes?
It is not clear, but the likelihood of finding anything that would be recognizable to us is highly unlikely . That is probably why the Return of the Ten Lost Tribes is the stuff of Messianic proportions.
The fate of the Ten Tribes is tragic, indeed. And in direct proportion, so is the rebuilding of their land.
This is why the rebuilding of Shomron today is so bewildering, marvelous and miraculous.
In the spirit of this past week’s public Torah reading, which describes the death of Rachel on the road, foreshadowing the exile of her children. But there is still home, and her children will indeed come back home again.
Thus said G-d: A cry is heard in Ramah— Wailing, bitter weeping— Rachel weeping for her children. She refuses to be comforted For her children, who are gone.
Thus said G-d: Restrain your voice from weeping, Your eyes from shedding tears; For there is a reward for your labor —declares G-d: They shall return from the enemy’s land.
And there is hope for your future —declares G-d: Your children shall return to their home. (Jeremiah 31:14-16)
 Cf. Yalkut Shimoni, Isaiah, 469.
 See also Cogan’s book Bound for Exile, Jerusalem: Carta 2013, which is a continuation of The Raging Torrent, and which focuses on the material about the exiles in their respective locations.
Note on the second edition of The Raging Torrent, for the connoisseur: There are significant differences between Cogan’s first and second editions, in terms of the sources used for Assyrian royal documents. I have asked the author about it. Prof. Cogan told me that Luckenbill’s two volume book included translations of the documents that were known in the beginning of the twentieth century. It was published in 1926-1927. However, more studies have emerged over the following decades and many more documents published, requiring revised translations. That is why he instead used Leichty for Esarhaddon, and more.
 Cf. Talmud Megillah 14b.
 The Mishnah in Sanhedrin (10:3) discusses the place of the Ten Tribes in the world to come, and the possibility of their return. Rashi points out that Jeremiah only brought back some of them.
 Translation taken from sefaria.org.
 Unfortunately, in stark contrast to the Olympics, contemporary with this period of time. The Olympics were panhellenistic rituals in honor of Zeus and Hera. Greek cities which were at war with each other, would lay down their arms, and compete for glory, through sports!
 I owe thanks to Rabbi Joey Dweck for this perspective.
Cogan, M. The Raging Torrent, Historical Inscriptions from Assyria and Babylonia Relating to Ancient Israel. Second Updated & Expanded Edition. Carta, Jerusalem (2008).
לנדי, י. ואלה דברי ימי ירמיהו. תקופת ירמיהו הנביא: סקירה היסטורית, גיאוגרפית וארכיאולוגית
קולמוס הפצת ספרים, ירושלים (2016).י
Van de Mieroop, M. A History of the Ancient Near East ca. 3000-323 B.C. Second edition. Blackwell Publishing (2007).
Photo: Hillel Mann, winemaker and owner of Beit El winery, examining his vineyard. Photo Credit: Beit El Winery
“Have you ever seen a prophecy come true?
…Would you like to hold one in your hand?”
That is how I opened up my sixth grade history class in Jerusalem, seven years ago (2010).
It was inspired by a very powerful experience on that year’s Rosh Hashana in which, I recall, my family and guests consumed fourteen bottles of wine. I daresay that I was a key player in the consumption thereof, and my passion for Israeli wine has only increased over the years.
This is a story about wine, but mostly about the Shomron (Samaria – the capital of the Northern Kingdom of Israel and the Ten Lost Tribes, and a general name for the region). If you too enjoy good wine, especially Israeli wine, you will find some practical information in this series of articles. But even if not – you may discover wonderful things. This series of three articles is intended for the Three Weeks  in which we reconnect with the First and Second Temple destruction periods, so it will also focus on the rebuilding of the Land, appropriate as is for its aftermath.
This, being the first part, will lay the foundation for the discussion about the Shomron, and the context that makes its wines so special.
The second part will deal with the broader historical context of the story as well as less known details that are learned from Assyrian archaeology. Furthermore, it will raise some important questions regarding the nature of the Ten Lost Tribes.
For the third part, I interviewed two people who are involved in the rebuilding of Judea and Samaria in unique ways. The first is Tzvi (Greg) Lauren, co-founder of West Bank Wines, who is involved in the distribution of Israeli wines in the United States. The second is Gabi Sackett, co-founder of Build Up Israel, a nonprofit supporting community building projects in a unique way. The article will include audio and transcriptions, as well as important links and social media information.
Now back to the sixth grade history lesson. Actually, let’s go back to that Rosh Hashana in the Old City of Jerusalem, 2010.
On the second day of Rosh Hashana, my father was appointed to read the Haftarah, a selection of prophecy of comfort from the book of Jeremiah (31:1-20). Perhaps the most famous verse from that portion is “A cry is heard in Ramah— Wailing, bitter weeping— Rachel weeping for her children. She refuses to be comforted, for her children, who are gone.” (ibid, 15) A poignant description of the utter shock and devastation of the Exile of the Ten Tribes, which have been deported by several kings of the Neo-Assyrian Empire. But what moved him to tears, as he was reading, was an earlier verse:
I will build you firmly again, O Maiden Israel! Again you shall take up your timbrels and go forth to the rhythm of the dancers. Again you shall plant vineyards on the hills of Samaria; Men shall plant and live to enjoy them. (ibid, 4-5)
What was so moving about these verses? I did not really understand…but when I held one of the bottles in my hand during the next meal, it hit me. It was a bottle of Cabernet Sauvignon from Barkan Winery, and though later I discovered their vineyards are not actually in the Shomron, the Barkan industrial section is. I then realized that not only a winery in the Shomron, but a booming wine industry, was indeed the fulfillment of a prophecy which, in the disastrous times of the prophecy, was inconceivable. It was then that this lesson was born.
I saved that empty bottle of Cabernet Sauvignon, brought it to my 6th grade classroom, and made an entire lesson out of it.
Weep, oh Shomron!
So what exactly happened?
The short and familiar story is as follows: Pekah, King of Israel in the north allied with his northeastern neighbor Rezin, King of Aram (Damascus) against Ahaz in southern Judah (II Kings 16:5). They were part of a coalition to stop local kings from joining the Assyrian empire, whose main goal was keeping Assyria out of the geopolitical game in the region.
This didn’t turn out well for the coalition. Tiglath-pileser III came to the aid of Ahaz, accepting Judah as a vassal kingdom, killing Rezin and deporting large parts of the Kingdom of Israel twice over the course of a three year campaign. He deported the many captives and repopulated them across the Assyrian Empire, settling the Samaria hill country with deportees from other areas of the empire (I Chronicles 5:26, II Kings 15:29 and cf. Rashi on II Kings 17:1).
In the days of King Pekah of Israel, King Tiglath-pileser of Assyria came and captured Ijon, Abel-beth Maacah, Janoah, Kedesh, Hazor—Gilead, Galilee, the entire region of Naphtali; and he deported the inhabitants to Assyria. (II Kings 15:29)
Later, during the reign of Shalmaneser V, King Hosea of Israel was caught sending a convoy to Seis, King of Egypt, (II Kings 17:4-6), a clear act of rebellion against Assyria. Shalmaneser did not like it, and after a three-year siege over Shomron, the king of Assyria destroyed it, and deported all the remaining citizens of Israel across the empire.
…and the King of Assyria deported the Israelites to Assyria. He settled them in Calah, along the Habor [and] the River Gozan, and in the towns of Media. (II Kings 18:11)
Rashi (II Kings 17:1) adds a detail about Sennacherib deporting a small portion of the remaining Ten Tribes. He bases this on the Seder Olam. Speaking of the Seder Olam, it should be noted that only recently has this famous jewish chronological work been made available to the scientific community. Professor Chaim Milikowsky just released the very first – and long awaited – scientific publication (in Hebrew) .
I have not had the benefit of holding a copy in my hand, yet, but strongly encourage doing so.
In any event, this is the story we all know.
It is hard to imagine the magnitude of this devastation. The Ashkenazi current Jewish population is mostly from Judah and Benjamin, Levi, and perhaps a few scattered families from across the ten tribes. There are Sephardim with origin traditions from specific tribes. The primary reason there are “Jews” and Jewish communities in the world today is because the kingdom of Judah was left in place over a century afterwards, was exiled en masse by Babylon and stayed together in large groups, who are thus traceable in Europe and the East; and with some Jews staying in the Land, as described in Kings and in Ezra-Nehemiah.
While the Judahites were exiled they returned, rebuilt the Temple and Jerusalem – and, centuries later were exiled again and dispersed around the Roman world – and they have miraculously returned to the Land of Israel again, after nearly two millennia.
The Ten Tribes have not.
The Ten Tribes are… lost… we call them “The Ten Lost Tribes” because their whereabouts as a rule are indeed as yet unknown, despite a recent resurgence of research into their fate..
In the next article I will expand the story through archaeology and discuss some broader issues regarding the Ten Lost Tribes.
I would like to share with you a poignant lamentation about this topic. Every Tisha b’Av (the fast of the 9th of Av), Jews around the world sit on the ground in mourning, and recite different lamentations, composed over the last two millennia, which describe the horrors of the destruction, persecution, pogroms and holocaust which have transpired over the generations. Entire jewish communities which have been destroyed by the crusaders, the Spanish inquisition, burning of Torah scrolls and other horrors are remembered.
One of these lamentations is called “Samaria lifts up her voice”, by Solomon ibn Gabirol, an 11th century Spanish-Jewish poet and philosopher. Translation is from the Tisha B’av Compendium, Judaica Press, NY 1989 and I have only brought the part relevant to this article, but you can research the entire lamentation at your leisure.
Some things to notice:
First of all, the lamentation attributes the exile only to Tiglath-pileser. Perhaps for poetic reason, he also only includes several of the locations to where the tribes were exiled.
Second, the name of Shomron is Aholoh (אָהֳלָה), literally translates as “His Tent”. This name appears in the full length of the lamentation, in which Jerusalem and Shomron bemoan their disastrous fate, and compare them one against the other’s. While “His Tent” is clearly a reference to the Tabernacle, which was in Shiloh, in the Shomron for 369 years , it is also a curious reference to wine . Indeed, the iniquities of the kingdom of Shomron – and their subsequent exile – have a lot to do with wine:
They drink [straight] from the wine bowls and anoint themselves with the choicest oils—but they are not concerned about the ruin of Joseph. Assuredly, right soon they shall head the column of exiles; They shall loll no more at festive meals. (Amos 6:6-7)
 “The Three Weeks” is the period in which Jews consciously engage with the nature of the destructions which have befallen the Jewish People (Maimonides, Mishne Torah, Laws of Fasts 5:1-4). The three weeks is the span of time between two National fast days, corresponding to the approximate date of the two final stages of the destruction of both Temples in Jerusalem: The breach of the walls of Jerusalem (17 of Tammuz) and the burning of the Temple (9 of Av).
 Seder Olam: Critical Edition, Commentary, and Introduction. Milikowsky, Chaim (2013): Yad Ben-Zvi Press, Israel
 Maimonides, Mishne Torah, Laws of the Chosen Temple 1:2
 The word “Aholo” is also found in the story of Noah’s drunkenness (Gen. 9:21), where he was exposed in his own tent, naked. The word for nakedness and exposure in Hebrew (va’yit’gal) is the same as Exile (gal’ut). See Rashi’s commentary on that verse.
Image Posted on Updated on
Summer Public Tanach Tours are over
Public tours will resume shortly, and a schedule will be posted soon.
It has been a long summer, with nearly 20 Tanach and Jewish History tours running at the Met. The summer Public Tanach Tour series is now complete, and we are gearing up for the year.
Follow Torah Intermedia to learn about upcoming tours, lectures and programs, as well as articles and reviews.
Thank you so much for an amazing tour of the MET with my children! You were so engaging with my children and managed to still fill the rest of the tour for us adults with lots of meaningful content! I will recommend you to anyone looking for a great tour guide of the MET and specifically a Jewish tour. You were great!!!
“Our extended family, ranging in age from 7 to 65, enjoyed a wonderful tour of the Met with Nachliel. He planned scavenger hunts, decryption games, and more to keep the younger crowd interested while engaging the adults with his vast knowledge. The tour brought the museum to life. I highly recommend it!”
Thank you Nachliel providing us all a great understanding of the Assyrian and Babylonian empires and their connection to Tanach!
We so enjoyed having Nachliel as our guide at the Metropolitan Museum of Art. Our group had been studying rabbinic materials about idolatry and Nachliel helped bring those issues to life through the Met’s collections. His comfort both with the ancient and classic sculpture we looked at as well as his fluency in Bible and rabbinic literature were terrific!
“Fascinating…Truly eye opening into the world we only hear about. The connection of Ancient Artifacts and the Tanach is explained and put into perspective, especially in this troubled time. This tour only reinforces our Historical connection to the Holy Land of Israel”
Jeff and Chery Klein from Monsey, NY. Participated July 23
This your is a great way to be introduced to the history of the Ancient Near East! It’s very comprehensive and spans a pretty good range of time. I also loved that it was grounded (corroborated) by passages of Tanakh. I loved seeing the intersection between the written record of history and Torah! Personally, I would have loved to spend more time on the text itself, but it’s hard to do it all in under two hours. I recommend this for anyone who’s interested in the A.N.E.!
Malka Rappaport from Crown Heights, NY. Participated Wednesday, July 12
Powerful presentation of the era of kings – Regional Kingdoms and Empires…the separation of Israel and Judea and eventual destruction of Jerusalem and the beginning of the Babylonian diaspora. Nachliel is a passionate guide and very informed and well traveled in order to present his material.
Notes were very well researched and presented. This tour was made even more powerful during the period of the three weeks between Tammuz and Tisha b’Av.
– Aliyana Wasserman, Rosanne Koenigson from Edison, NJ. Participated Sunday, July 16
“I’ve lived in New York City my entire life and have been through the Metropolitan Museum of Art…many times. Nachliel made me feel like I was touring these wings for the first time.”
“Nachliel is exceptionally knowledgeable and passionate about his twin loves – Torah and Archeology. He showed us the importance of contextualizing II Melakhim and Yirmiyahu in its Ancient Near Eastern setting…We moved at a rapid-fire pace…”